Forensic extraction vs a TextExhibit export: the real differences

Short answer

A forensic extraction copies data from the device with specialized tools and a documented method, while a TextExhibit export reads messages from a backup or the Messages app and formats them as a PDF, CSV and HTML. They answer different questions: the first is about the device and recovered data, the second is about a readable, complete record of the messages on it.

TextExhibit PDF page listing each attachment with its size and SHA-256 hash, then the start of the transcript with delivered and read times
Attachments listed with their SHA-256 hashes, then the transcript. From an export of made-up sample messages.

Side by side

  • Source: forensic, the device itself; TextExhibit, an iPhone backup, a cable backup or Messages on the Mac.
  • Deleted data: forensic may find some; TextExhibit shows what is in the backup.
  • Output: forensic, an image and a report; TextExhibit, a PDF with cover page, CSV, HTML, attachments and a hash list.
  • Skills: forensic needs a trained examiner; TextExhibit is for anyone with a Mac.
  • Cost and time: forensic is usually higher and slower; TextExhibit costs $24.99 one time and runs in minutes.
  • Testimony: a forensic examiner can testify about method; TextExhibit users describe the steps they took.

Choose by the question

If the question is what was said and when, an export may be enough. If the question is whether the device or the data was altered, or what was deleted, choose forensics.

Using both

Some matters use an export for review and keep a forensic image in reserve.

Cost and time in practice

An export can be done at a desk in a short time and costs the price of one license. A forensic extraction involves scheduling, shipping or travel, an examiner's hourly or fixed fee, and a written report. Neither is better in general. The right one depends on what the case needs to show.

What to keep in mind

  • This is general information for professionals, not legal advice or investigative guidance for any specific matter. Rules and local practice differ.
  • TextExhibit does not bypass passcodes or recover deleted messages.
  • Courts and parties decide what form is required.

Questions

Is an export forensically sound?

It is a copy with a hash list. It is not a forensic image.

Can I start with an export?

Yes, and escalate if needed.

Will the other side object?

They might. Discuss early.

Export the whole conversation

TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.