Full Disk Access is on but the app still cannot read Messages
Quit the app completely and reopen it, because Full Disk Access only applies to a freshly launched app. If that does not help, remove the app from the list and add it again, then check there is only one copy and no management profile.
In order
- Quit the app (Command-Q), not just close the window.
- Open it again.
- In System Settings, Privacy & Security, Full Disk Access, click minus on the app, then plus, and add the copy in Applications.
- Restart the Mac.
Other causes
- Two copies of the app, so you gave access to the wrong one.
- A management profile blocks the setting; look under System Settings, General, Device Management.
- You are not signed in as an administrator.
- The app is running from a disk image rather than from Applications. Copy it to Applications first.
Or it has access but finds nothing
If the app opens but shows no conversations or only a few, the Messages database may truly be small. That happens when Messages in iCloud is off on this Mac. Use the iPhone as the source instead. See exporting without iCloud.
Check with Terminal
Advanced users can test with Terminal if Terminal itself has access, using ls on ~/Library/Messages. If Terminal can list it and the app cannot, the problem is the app’s entry.
A decision tree
- Prompt keeps appearing: quit completely and reopen.
- Prompt gone but list empty: the Mac holds no history; use the iPhone.
- Toggle greyed out: a profile or no admin rights.
- Toggle missing for the app: add it with the plus button.
Examples
Someone downloads the app, drags it to Applications, opens it from the disk image and grants access to the copy in the disk image. Later they open the Applications copy and nothing works. Granting access to the Applications copy fixes it.
What to keep in mind
- Do not disable System Integrity Protection to work around this. It is unnecessary and weakens your Mac.
- Management profiles can only be removed by whoever installed them.
- Permission changes may need an administrator password.
Questions
Do I need to restart the Mac?
Usually quitting and reopening the app is enough.
Why does it ask again each time?
Probably the app is being run from a different location each time.
Is it safe to leave on?
It is better to turn it off after use.
Sources
- Set up Messages on Mac (Apple) (checked November 15, 2026)
Export the whole conversation
TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.