How HR investigators use text messages in workplace investigations

Short answer

Ask each person to hand over the relevant thread voluntarily, export it with sender, date and time, and keep a consistent record of how each person's texts were collected. Consistency matters: if you collect from one side, offer the same to the other.

TextExhibit PDF page listing each attachment with its size and SHA-256 hash, then the start of the transcript with delivered and read times
Attachments listed with their SHA-256 hashes, then the transcript. From an export of made-up sample messages.

Practical steps

  1. Decide the scope and the date range with the person overseeing the investigation.
  2. Ask for consent and explain how the messages will be used and stored.
  3. Export the thread on a Mac with TextExhibit or ask the person to forward screenshots if they have no Mac.
  4. Compare timestamps with other evidence like emails and badge logs.
  5. Record the source and handling.
  6. Store files in the investigation file with limited access.

Things to watch

  • Personal phones belong to the person, so participation is usually voluntary.
  • Company phones may be covered by policy. Ask counsel.
  • Group chats include people who are not part of the matter.
  • Screenshots may leave out context.

Neutral reporting

Quote messages as exported and avoid paraphrasing in a way that adds meaning. Attach the PDF pages you rely on.

Fairness and records

Treat both sides the same way: ask each for relevant threads, in the same form, and apply the same date range. Record who gave what and when. If someone declines, record that too.

In your report, separate what the messages say from your conclusions, and cite pages. If the thread contradicts a witness, say so neutrally and give the witness a chance to respond.

Anonymous reports

If a complaint is anonymous, you may have only screenshots forwarded by a third party. Treat them as leads, not as verified evidence, and look for ways to confirm them from the participants' own phones with consent. Record the limits of what you could verify.

What to keep in mind

  • This is general information for professionals, not legal advice or investigative guidance for any specific matter. Rules and local practice differ.
  • Employment and privacy rules differ by place.
  • Do not pressure employees to hand over personal phones.

Questions

Can I require an employee to hand over texts?

That depends on policy and law. Ask counsel.

Is a screenshot enough?

It may do for a first look. A full export shows more.

How long do I keep the files?

Per retention policy.

Export the whole conversation

TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.