How insurance adjusters use text messages in claims

Short answer

Ask the claimant or insured for the full thread about the event, not selected screenshots, in a form that shows sender, date and time. Text threads can confirm times, locations and statements, and a complete export lets you check the context.

TextExhibit PDF page listing each attachment with its size and SHA-256 hash, then the start of the transcript with delivered and read times
Attachments listed with their SHA-256 hashes, then the transcript. From an export of made-up sample messages.

Where texts show up in claims

  • Messages between drivers after an accident.
  • Messages to a contractor about damage and repairs.
  • Messages with a landlord or neighbor.
  • Messages about a loss date or the sequence of events.

How to ask

  1. Explain which thread and dates you need.
  2. Offer simple options: a PDF export if they have a Mac, or full screenshots with times visible.
  3. Ask for the phone number or number of the other person.
  4. Record how and when you received the material.

Using the record

Compare message times with photos, repair estimates and reports. Note any gaps. Keep a copy in the claim file.

A short example

A claimant says a delivery van hit his parked car at 3 pm on a Tuesday. He supplies a thread with the driver in which the driver writes at 3:21 pm that he is sorry about the dent and will cover it. The adjuster asks for the full export so she can see what came before and after, and notes the numbers on each message.

She then compares the 3:21 message with the van's route log and the repair estimate, records the source in the claim file, and sends the file to the claims lawyer if liability is disputed. She does not draw conclusions about authorship from the thread alone.

Third-party claims

If you receive texts from a third-party claimant's lawyer or from a witness, treat them like any other evidence: record the source, keep the original, and avoid altering them. If the texts appear to conflict with a recorded statement, note both and let the claims or legal team decide.

What to keep in mind

  • This is general information for professionals, not legal advice or investigative guidance for any specific matter. Rules and local practice differ.
  • Claims handling rules and privacy laws differ.
  • Do not ask for access to a phone beyond what is relevant.
  • An export shows messages, not who typed them.

Questions

Can I require a PDF?

Check your policy and the claimant's ability.

What if the claimant refuses?

Ask your supervisor or counsel.

Does it show photos?

Yes, inline.

Export the whole conversation

TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.