Should you keep texts as a PDF or a printed book?

Short answer

Keep a PDF as your master copy and print a book from it only for the parts you want to hold in your hands. A PDF can be searched and copied to several drives for free, while a printed book can be lost in a flood or fire and cannot be searched.

TextExhibit PDF page with two photos shown in place, each with file name, size and SHA-256 hash, and a reply quoting the message it answers
Photos in place with file name, size and hash, and a reply that quotes its message. From an export of made-up sample messages.

PDF

  • Searchable, copyable, free to keep in several places.
  • File formats change slowly, and PDF has been stable for decades.
  • Needs a device, which can be lost or outdated.

Printed book

  • Easy to hand to someone who does not use a computer.
  • Lasts as long as the paper does.
  • Costs money and shelf space, and cannot be searched.

A sensible combination

  1. Export the PDF and the manifest with TextExhibit.
  2. Copy the folder to two places: an external drive and a cloud folder you trust.
  3. Print the best chapters.
  4. Check the files every year or two.

How to keep a PDF safe for decades

Copy the folder to at least two places that fail in different ways, such as an external drive in a drawer and a cloud folder. Check every year that the files still open. When you buy a new computer, copy the folder across before you sell the old one.

Keep the manifest file next to the PDF. It lists every exported file with its SHA-256 hash, so years later you can show the file is the one you made.

What to keep in mind

  • PDFs depend on future software to open them, but it is a widely supported format.
  • A printed book has only what you printed.
  • Backups of backups need a little upkeep.
  • Passwords on an encrypted drive need to be kept too.

Questions

Is PDF/A better for keeping?

It is built for long-term storage. See what PDF/A is.

Do I need the manifest?

The manifest lists every file and its hash, so you can later check nothing changed.

Can I keep both HTML and PDF?

Yes, both can be exported.

How often should I check my archive?

Once a year is plenty. Open the PDF, scroll a few pages and make sure the drive still mounts.

Export the whole conversation

TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.