What happens to Live Photos and HEIC pictures in an exported conversation?

Short answer

A photo from a conversation appears on the page as a still picture, and the original file is copied to the attachments folder, where a Live Photo may be a picture plus a short video. HEIC is Apple's photo format; Mac opens it in Preview, and you can export a JPEG from there if another computer cannot read it.

TextExhibit PDF page with two photos shown in place, each with file name, size and SHA-256 hash, and a reply quoting the message it answers
Photos in place with file name, size and hash, and a reply that quotes its message. From an export of made-up sample messages.

On the page and in the folder

  • On the page: a still image at the point it was sent.
  • In the folder: the original photo as stored. Live Photos can come as a still and a movie.
  • In the manifest: each file with a SHA-256 hash.

Opening and converting HEIC

  1. Open the file in Preview on a Mac.
  2. Choose File, Export, and set Format to JPEG or PNG.
  3. Save the copy next to the original. Keep the original untouched.

Why it matters

For some matters the file itself, with its details such as the time it was taken, matters more than the printout. Keep the original files and do not edit or rename them. A converted JPEG can lose some details; treat it as a convenience copy. See photos in exports.

Checking details in Preview

Open a photo in Preview and use Tools, Show Inspector, then the "i" tab, to see its size, its format and, when it exists, the date it was taken. Photos sent through Messages often lose some of this data, so a missing field is not a sign of tampering. If the original details matter, ask the person who took the photo for the original file from their own phone, and keep the one from the conversation as a separate item.

What to keep in mind

  • Many apps and carriers shrink or convert images before delivery, so an image received may not have the details of the original.
  • Live Photos motion does not appear on paper.

Questions

Do Windows computers open HEIC?

Newer versions can with an add-on; JPEG is easier.

Is location data in the photo?

Messages may strip it when sending. Check the file in Preview, Tools, Show Inspector.

Does the export alter the photo?

It copies the file. The manifest hash lets you check.

Can I tell when a photo was taken?

Sometimes, if the file still has its details. The message time shows when it was sent.

Does the export convert HEIC to JPEG?

It copies the original. Convert only in a copy.

Export the whole conversation

TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.