How mediators handle text messages shared in mediation
Ask each side to bring the full thread for the period at issue rather than excerpts, and keep the handling confidential per your mediation agreement. Mediators do not rule on evidence, but a complete record helps parties see what was actually said.
Practical points
- Ask in advance what messages each side will bring.
- A full thread avoids arguments about what was left out.
- Printouts with date and time let you refer to a page and a line.
- Treat messages as confidential within the mediation rules.
In the room
- Agree on which messages to read together.
- Refer to page and time.
- Pause if a message shows something risky or private.
- Do not make credibility findings.
After mediation
Remind parties that what they share is covered by the confidentiality agreement and applicable law, and that originals stay with them.
A short preparation checklist
Ask each side for the thread in the same form, ideally a PDF with date and time on every message, and agree who prints copies. Tell them you will read from the pages, so the page numbers should match.
Remind parties that you may stop discussion of a message if it raises safety concerns, and that you may be required to follow rules on reporting. Keep any notes limited to what your agreement allows.
When messages raise safety issues
If a thread contains threats or signs of abuse, the mediator may need to end a session, speak to parties separately or refer them to resources, in line with the mediator's rules and the agreement. Keep your notes within what is allowed.
If one side hands over messages of a person who is not at the table, remind them that the messages may involve a third party's privacy.
What to keep in mind
- This is general information for professionals, not legal advice or investigative guidance for any specific matter. Rules and local practice differ.
- Confidentiality rules differ by state and agreement.
- Mediators should not give legal advice.
Questions
Can I ask for texts?
Yes, as part of preparation if parties agree.
Should I keep copies?
Follow your policy.
What about edited messages?
Exports mark edited and unsent messages.
Export the whole conversation
TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.