Messages in iCloud: Disable This Device versus Disable All

Short answer

Disable This Device stops syncing on that Mac only, while Disable All turns Messages in iCloud off on every device on your Apple Account. If you only want your Mac to stop syncing, choose Disable This Device, and make a backup first either way.

TextExhibit showing a connected iPhone and a Back Up Now button
An iPhone connected by cable, ready to back up. The device shown is a sample.

Where you see them

On the Mac, untick Enable Messages in iCloud in Messages, Settings, iMessage. The Mac then asks which of the two you want.

Disable This Device

  • Only this Mac stops syncing.
  • Your iPhone and other Macs keep using Messages in iCloud.
  • Use it when you want to freeze a Mac’s copy or stop it using disk space.

Disable All

  • Turns the feature off on all devices and stops using iCloud for messages, as Apple describes it.
  • Afterwards texts are saved in your next iCloud Backup instead.
  • Use it only when you are sure, and after making a Finder backup. See turning it off safely.

What it means for exporting

Export before you change anything. TextExhibit reads whatever is currently on the Mac, so a Mac that you have disabled may not hold the whole history.

A worked example

Imagine a home Mac, a work Mac and an iPhone, all on Messages in iCloud. You want the work Mac to stop holding personal messages. You choose Disable This Device on the work Mac. The home Mac and iPhone keep syncing, and the work Mac keeps only what it had downloaded. If you had chosen Disable All instead, all three would stop using iCloud for messages, which is rarely what you wanted.

Questions to ask yourself first

  • Do I need the full history on this Mac later?
  • Is another device keeping a complete copy?
  • Have I exported or backed up the threads that matter?
  • Is anything in the thread time-sensitive, such as a dispute?

What to keep in mind

  • The labels are Apple’s and may change with macOS updates.
  • Neither choice is a deletion tool, but do not rely on iCloud holding a copy afterwards.
  • Do not use Disable All as a way to free iPhone space.

Questions

Which is safer?

Disable This Device.

Does either one delete texts on my iPhone?

Apple does not describe either as a deletion, but check the prompts on your iPhone.

Can I turn it back on?

Yes, in the same place, and the Mac will sync again.

Sources

Export the whole conversation

TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.