How to keep a production log and hash manifest for text messages

Short answer

Keep a production log with one line per file, using the manifest that TextExhibit writes, which lists every exported file with its SHA-256 hash. A hash is a fingerprint: if a file changes by even one character, its hash changes.

TextExhibit PDF page listing each attachment with its size and SHA-256 hash, then the start of the transcript with delivered and read times
Attachments listed with their SHA-256 hashes, then the transcript. From an export of made-up sample messages.

What goes in the log

  • Production volume or letter number and date.
  • File name and what it contains: the conversation, parties and date range.
  • Bates range.
  • SHA-256 hash from the manifest.
  • Method of delivery.
  • Redactions and their reasons.

How to use the manifest

  1. Export each conversation. Keep the manifest in the same folder.
  2. Copy the file names and hashes into your log.
  3. Before sending and after, verify a hash with Terminal: shasum -a 256 filename.
  4. Store the manifest where it cannot be edited casually.

Why it helps

If someone asks later whether a file was altered, matching hashes help show it was not. See what a hash is.

A sample log line

A line might read: Volume 1, March 14, file SMITH_Jones_thread.pdf, text conversation between J. Smith and A. Jones, March 1 to May 31, SMITH000001 to SMITH000142, SHA-256 beginning 9f2c, delivered by secure link. A second line lists the CSV with the same date range and its own hash.

Add a column for redactions and one for privilege withheld. If a file is replaced, do not delete the old line. Add a new one and say why, so the log shows the history.

Storing logs safely

Treat the log like any privileged work product. Store it with the matter, restrict access, and keep dated versions. If the log is shared with the other side, share the version that is meant for them, with only the columns they should see.

What to keep in mind

  • This is general information for professionals, not legal advice. Rules and local practice differ, so check the governing rules, the court's orders and your supervising attorney.
  • A hash shows a file is the same as when it was hashed. It does not show the messages were authentic to start with.
  • Redaction or re-export changes the hash.

Questions

Is a log required?

Often useful. Ask the attorney.

Who keeps the originals?

The producing firm, per its policy.

Can the other side check hashes?

Yes, if you give them the list.

Export the whole conversation

TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.