Should you redact phone numbers or private details from text messages before sharing?

Short answer

Redaction means hiding parts of a document, and it is sometimes needed for other people's numbers, account codes or private details, but TextExhibit has no redaction tool, so you have to do it afterward on a copy. Never redact the only copy: keep the original export untouched, and ask your lawyer or the person who asked for the document what must be hidden and how, because hiding the wrong thing can cause problems.

TextExhibit PDF page showing a reaction, an edited message with its edit time, an unsent message, and SMS messages marked as SMS
A reaction, an edited message, an unsent message and SMS texts, each marked. From an export of made-up sample messages.

What people often redact

  • Phone numbers or email addresses of third parties.
  • Account numbers, passwords and one-time codes.
  • Home addresses and children's names.
  • Medical or financial details unrelated to the matter.

Ask first

Courts, agencies and employers can have rules about what may or must be redacted, and some want redactions marked in a particular way. Changing a document that is evidence can also raise questions. Ask your lawyer or the clerk before you hide anything, and never hide something because it is unhelpful to you.

A safe workflow

  1. Export the full conversation with TextExhibit and keep that folder untouched, with its manifest.
  2. Make a copy of the PDF and name it so it is clearly the redacted one, for example texts-redacted.pdf.
  3. Redact the copy properly; see how to black out text in a PDF with Preview.
  4. Check the result by trying to select and search the hidden text.
  5. Say on the document or in a note that it has been redacted, and why.

Where redaction can go wrong

The usual mistakes are covering text with a box but leaving it under the box, forgetting the file's name or properties, and redacting only one place where the same number appears three times. Another is hiding something that the other side is entitled to see. Always read the redacted copy from top to bottom, search for the hidden words and numbers, and have a second person check it.

What to keep in mind

  • Drawing a black box over text does not delete the text underneath. See the Preview how-to page.
  • Redaction changes the file, so the hash of the redacted copy will not match the manifest. That is expected; keep the original and the manifest.

Questions

Does the app have a hide-numbers option?

No redaction tool. There is an option to show names or numbers; see showing numbers.

Can I just crop a screenshot?

Cropping hides part of a picture but makes the screenshot less complete. Ask first.

Who decides what to redact?

The rules where you are, your lawyer, or whoever requested the document.

Should I tell people I redacted?

Yes, say it on the document.

Can redaction be undone?

If done properly, no. That is why you keep the original.

Export the whole conversation

TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.