Text messages as evidence in Canada
In Canada, text messages are electronic documents: under section 31.1 of the Canada Evidence Act the person offering them must prove authenticity with evidence capable of supporting a finding that they are what they claim to be, and provinces have similar rules for cases under provincial law, such as section 34.1 of Ontario’s Evidence Act. Keep the phone and the full thread, make free copies first (screenshots with times, or Print from Messages on a Mac), and be ready to explain how the copy was made and that the phone was working normally.
Which law applies
Section 2 of the Canada Evidence Act says Part I applies to all criminal proceedings and to all civil proceedings and other matters respecting which Parliament has jurisdiction. Most family, small claims and other civil cases are governed by provincial evidence law, and provinces have their own electronic records provisions. Ontario’s Evidence Act section 34.1, for example, uses almost the same wording. See the province pages: Ontario family court, Ontario Small Claims Court, British Columbia, Alberta and Quebec.
Canada Evidence Act, sections 31.1 to 31.3, in plain English
- 31.1 Authentication: anyone seeking to admit an electronic document has the burden of proving its authenticity by evidence capable of supporting a finding that it is what it is claimed to be. For texts, that is usually someone who sent or received them, plus the number, content and context.
- 31.2(1) Best evidence rule: for an electronic document, the rule is satisfied by proof of the integrity of the electronic documents system that recorded or stored it.
- 31.2(2) Printouts: without evidence to the contrary, a printout satisfies the best evidence rule if it has been manifestly or consistently acted on, relied on or used as a record of the information.
- 31.3 Presumption of integrity: integrity is proven, without evidence to the contrary, by evidence that the computer system or similar device was operating properly (or that any malfunction did not affect the document), or if the document was recorded or stored by a party adverse in interest to the party offering it.
What that means for your iPhone messages
- Your phone is the ‘device’. Be ready to say it was working normally and that you did not alter the messages.
- 31.3(b) is worth knowing: integrity is also presumed if the document was recorded or stored by a party adverse in interest to the one offering it, for example messages taken from the other side’s own records. Ask your lawyer how it fits your case.
- Section 31.6 lets some of these matters be proved by affidavit, and the other side may cross-examine the person who swore it.
- Section 31.5 lets evidence be presented about standards, procedures or practices for recording and storing electronic documents.
Making a copy you can explain
- Keep the conversation on the phone and keep the phone. Do not reset it or trade it in during the case.
- Back up the iPhone to a Mac with Finder (General, Back Up Now).
- Export the whole thread or a full date range. TextExhibit on a Mac makes one PDF with the date and time to the second and time zone, sender names and numbers, page numbers and an exhibit label. Its cover page records the source, device and how the copy was made, and a manifest lists a SHA-256 hash of every exported file.
- If you swear an affidavit about the copy, describe these steps in plain words.
What to keep in mind
- This is general information, not legal advice. Quebec civil law has its own rules; see the Quebec page.
- Hearsay is a separate question from authentication. Whether a statement in a message can be used for its truth is for the court; ask a lawyer.
- TextExhibit reads iPhone Messages only and cannot recover messages deleted before a backup.
Questions
Are screenshots of texts admissible in Canada?
They can be, if authenticity is proven and the best evidence rule for electronic documents is satisfied. Complete copies with dates and numbers are easier to defend. See are screenshots admissible.
Does the Canada Evidence Act apply to my family or small claims case?
Part I applies to criminal proceedings and civil matters within federal jurisdiction. Many family and civil cases are under provincial law, where the province’s evidence act applies; provinces such as Ontario have similar electronic records rules.
Do I need an expert to authenticate texts in Canada?
Section 31.1 sets a low threshold: evidence capable of supporting a finding of authenticity. Often your own testimony is the starting point. If the other side alleges tampering, more may be needed.
Sources
- Canada Evidence Act (R.S.C. 1985, c. C-5), full text (checked November 15, 2026)
- Ontario Evidence Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. E.23, s. 34.1 (checked November 15, 2026)
Export the whole conversation
TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.