Text messages as evidence in Tennessee

Short answer

In Tennessee, a text message is usually shown to be genuine under Tennessee Rule of Evidence 901, most often by someone who sent or received it testifying that it is what you say it is, supported by details like the phone number, the content and the context. Start for free with screenshots (swipe left so each message shows its time) or File, Print from Messages on a Mac, keep the phone unchanged, and ask your lawyer or the court clerk what format the court wants.

Transcript page of a TextExhibit PDF: each message with the time to the second and time zone, the sender’s name and phone number, page number and Bates number
A transcript page: time to the second, sender, number, page and Bates number. From an export of made-up sample messages.

Rule 901: showing the texts are what you say they are

Tennessee Rule of Evidence 901(a) says authentication is satisfied by evidence sufficient to the court to support a finding that the matter is what its proponent claims. The Advisory Commission Comment adds that the trial judge decides authentication questions.

Rule 901(b) gives examples, and says they are illustrations only, not a complete list. Three of them fit text messages well:

  • 901(b)(1), testimony of a witness with knowledge: you, as the person who received the messages, say this is the conversation and this is the other person’s number.
  • 901(b)(4), distinctive characteristics: the appearance, contents, substance and internal patterns of the messages, taken with the circumstances. Nicknames, plans only the two of you knew about, and replies that fit your messages all count here.
  • 901(b)(9), process or system: evidence describing a process that produces an accurate result. The comment to the rule says this subsection treats authentication of computer documents. A record of how an export was made can help here.

Hearsay: Rules 802 and 803(1.2)

Rule 802 says hearsay is not admissible except as provided by the rules or otherwise by law. A text is often offered to prove what it says, so hearsay comes up.

Tennessee lists the main exception for texts from the other side in Rule 803(1.2), admission by party-opponent: a statement offered against a party that is the party’s own statement. In plain English, the other side’s own messages can usually be used against them, though the rule also says such statements are not conclusive. Your own messages, offered by you, are a different question. Your lawyer can say which exception, if any, fits.

Rules 1001 and 1002: is a printout an original?

Rule 1002 requires the original to prove the content of a writing or recording, except as the rules or statutes provide. Rule 1001(3) then says that if data are stored in a computer or similar device, any printout or other output readable by sight and shown to reflect the data accurately is an original. A phone is such a device, so an accurate printout of the conversation can serve as the original. The comment to Rule 1002 also notes that courts usually admit machine copies.

Making a copy that holds up

  1. Keep the phone and the conversation. Do not delete, reset or trade in the phone while the case is open.
  2. For a few messages, take screenshots after swiping left so each message shows its time. Note the date shown above each group.
  3. For a long thread, use a Mac: File, Print from Messages if the conversation syncs there, or make a backup in Finder (General, Back Up Now) so you have a frozen copy.
  4. If you need every message with the date and time to the second and the sender’s number, TextExhibit exports one conversation to a PDF with page numbers, optional Bates numbers and an exhibit label, plus a SHA-256 manifest so anyone can check later that the files did not change.
  5. Write down when and how you made the copy. That supports the Rule 901 testimony.

What to keep in mind

  • This is general information about Tennessee’s rules, not legal advice. The judge decides whether any exhibit comes in.
  • An export shows what is on the phone or in the backup. It does not prove who typed a message; testimony and other evidence do that.
  • Rules change. Check the current text on the Tennessee courts website before relying on it.

Questions

Are screenshots enough in a Tennessee court?

Sometimes, if a witness can authenticate them under Rule 901. Screenshots can leave out dates, numbers and context, so a full export is often easier to defend. See are screenshots admissible.

Is a printout of my texts an original or a copy?

Under Tennessee Rule of Evidence 1001(3), a printout of data stored on a computer or similar device is an original if it is shown to reflect the data accurately.

Can the other side’s texts be used against them?

Often, yes. Tennessee Rule 803(1.2) treats a party’s own statement, offered against that party, as an exception to the hearsay rule. Ask your lawyer how it applies to your messages.

Who decides if the texts are authentic?

The trial judge decides whether there is enough evidence to authenticate them, according to the Advisory Commission Comment to Rule 901.

Sources

Export the whole conversation

TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.