Text messages as evidence in Wisconsin

Short answer

Wisconsin courts generally treat text messages like other documents: whoever offers them must be able to show they are what they claim to be, usually through testimony from someone in the conversation plus the number, content and context, and the Wisconsin courts tell people that evidence on a phone must be printed out or saved to a storage device to submit. Make free copies first (screenshots after swiping left, or Print from Messages on a Mac), keep the phone and the full thread, and ask your lawyer or the clerk how that court wants exhibits presented.

Transcript page of a TextExhibit PDF: each message with the time to the second and time zone, the sender’s name and phone number, page number and Bates number
A transcript page: time to the second, sender, number, page and Bates number. From an export of made-up sample messages.

Where Wisconsin’s evidence rules are

Wisconsin’s rules of evidence are in its statutes. The Wisconsin State Law Library lists them as chapters 901 to 911 of the Wisconsin Statutes, with related material in chapter 885 (witnesses and oral testimony) and chapter 889 (documentary and record evidence). We could not reach the Legislature’s statutes site when writing this guide, so we do not quote individual sections; read them there or ask a lawyer.

The two questions most courts ask about texts

  • Authentication: is this really the conversation, and did this person send these messages? Usually answered by a witness who took part, plus the phone number, details only the sender would know, and replies that fit. See how texts are shown to be real.
  • Hearsay: is a statement in the message being used to prove it is true? Courts often treat the other party’s own statements differently from statements by people who are not in the case. Your lawyer will know how Wisconsin handles each message.

Wisconsin’s practical instruction: print it

The Wisconsin court system’s Basic Guide to Wisconsin Small Claims Actions (form SC-6000V) says evidence on cell phones, computers or other electronic devices must be printed out or saved to a storage device to submit to the court, and recommends bringing copies of all documents for the court and all other parties. That guide is about small claims, but it is a good habit in any Wisconsin case: do not count on handing the judge your phone.

Making the copies

  1. Keep the thread on the phone. Do not delete it, rename the contact or reset the phone while the case is open.
  2. Back up the iPhone on a Mac with Finder (General, Back Up Now).
  3. For a few messages, swipe left in Messages to show times, then screenshot. On a Mac that syncs Messages, File, Print saves a PDF.
  4. For a long thread, TextExhibit on a Mac exports one PDF with the date and time to the second, the sender’s number, page numbers, optional Bates numbers and an exhibit label, plus a SHA-256 manifest. Save the PDF to a USB drive as well as printing it, so you can submit it either way.

Which Wisconsin page next

What to keep in mind

  • This is general information, not legal advice. Whether an exhibit is admitted is up to the judge or court commissioner.
  • We did not verify individual Wisconsin evidence statutes for this page; check chapters 901 to 911 before relying on a specific rule.
  • An export does not prove who typed a message. If authorship is disputed, carrier records or a forensic exam may be needed.

Questions

Can I show the judge texts on my phone in Wisconsin?

The Wisconsin courts’ small claims guide says evidence on cell phones must be printed out or saved to a storage device to submit. Bring printed copies, and the phone as backup.

Are screenshots admissible in Wisconsin?

They can be, if the court is satisfied they are authentic and they meet the other rules. Screenshots often miss dates and numbers. See are screenshots admissible.

Where are Wisconsin’s rules of evidence?

In chapters 901 to 911 of the Wisconsin Statutes, according to the Wisconsin State Law Library.

Sources

Export the whole conversation

TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.