Can text messages be used in small claims court in Delaware?

Short answer

Yes, text messages can be offered as evidence in a Delaware Justice of the Peace Court civil case, which is where Delaware's small claims go, for claims up to $25,000, but the court says the Delaware Rules of Evidence still apply there. Bring the messages as printed documents or as a PDF on a USB drive or disc, which the court lists among the formats it accepts, plus copies for the judge and the other side and the phone itself.

From opening a conversation to the exported files, in 30 seconds. Recorded in TextExhibit with its built-in sample conversations; the names and numbers are made up. Background music, no narration.

Delaware's "small claims" court

Delaware has no court named small claims. Money disputes of up to $25,000 go to the Justice of the Peace Court, which hears debt, contract, property damage (negligence without physical injury) and replevin cases, the last meaning the return of personal property. If your claim is larger, the court's filing page says you can limit it to $25,000, but you lose the right to the amount over that.

You do not need a lawyer, the court says, although one can help. Court clerks cannot give legal advice or fill out your papers, but the court publishes sample complaints, an interactive complaint form and a booklet on filing and defending a civil claim.

Less formal, but the Rules of Evidence apply

This is the Delaware detail people miss. The court's question-and-answer page on evidence says that although the Justice of the Peace Court is less formal than the higher courts, the Rules of Evidence must be followed, and the judge can consider only admissible evidence. So texts must be relevant, authenticated and not barred as hearsay.

Two points from that page help with texts. Statements by the other party can ordinarily be offered against them: "a plaintiff may offer anything a defendant says; a defendant may offer anything a plaintiff says." And under Rule 1003, a copy or computer printout can be used in place of the original unless there is a real question whether it is an exact copy, or using it would be unfair. More on this in text messages as evidence in Delaware.

Filing and what to bring

  1. Fill out the complaint (Civil Form No. 1). In it, describe the agreement, the incident, and the type and amount of damage. If a text is the agreement, say so and attach a copy.
  2. Make four copies of the complaint and any attachments. Keep one, and take or mail the original plus three copies to the court with the filing fee. A business that files five or more cases a year must eFile, after free eFlex training.
  3. Pick the messages that prove the deal, the promise, the notice or the damage, with enough context that nothing looks cut out.
  4. Get them on paper. Free: screenshots (swipe left first to show times), or on a Mac with Messages in iCloud, open the conversation and choose File > Print. Or use TextExhibit on a Mac to export the conversation or a date range to one PDF with the date, time and sender's number on every message and page numbers. Free with a watermark; $24.99 once removes it.
  5. Bring printed copies: one for the judge, one for the other side, one for you. The court's "What to Bring" page also lists CD, DVD or USB evidence and accepts .PDF among its formats. Ask the clerk if your court wants anything else.
  6. Bring witnesses who can back up the texts. If you are not sure a witness will come, request a subpoena at least five days before trial; the court lists a $5.00 fee per subpoena.

Your phone at court

Phones are allowed in Delaware court buildings with restrictions set out in the courts' Portable Electronic Devices policy, and all bags are searched. Bring the phone charged with the conversation still on it in case the other side says your printout was edited, but plan to rely on paper or a PDF rather than handing the judge your phone.

What to keep in mind

  • This is general information, not legal advice. The judge decides what is admitted. The court's evidence page itself says it is not a complete statement of the rules.
  • Either side can appeal a Justice of the Peace Court civil decision to the Court of Common Pleas, where the case is heard again from the start, so keep your copies and the phone after the trial.
  • An export cannot recover messages deleted before the backup was made.

Questions

What is the small claims limit in Delaware?

$25,000. The Justice of the Peace Court hears debt, trespass and replevin cases where the amount in controversy does not exceed $25,000.

Can I bring the texts on a USB drive?

The court's What to Bring page lists CD, DVD or USB evidence and accepts PDF files. Bring paper copies too, so the judge and the other side can read along.

Can I sue in Delaware for a text-message agreement worth more than $25,000?

Not in the Justice of the Peace Court for the full amount. You can limit your claim to $25,000 and give up the rest, or file in a higher court, where a lawyer is a good idea.

Sources

Export the whole conversation

TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.