What is spoliation of evidence?

Short answer

Spoliation is the destruction, loss or alteration of evidence when someone has a duty to preserve it, and courts can respond with penalties. For text messages, it can happen when someone deletes a thread, changes the Keep Messages setting, or wipes a phone after a dispute is likely.

Transcript page of a TextExhibit PDF: each message with the time to the second and time zone, the sender’s name and phone number, page number and Bates number
A transcript page: time to the second, sender, number, page and Bates number. From an export of made-up sample messages.

What it means in plain words

The duty to preserve can start before a lawsuit is filed, when litigation is reasonably foreseeable, depending on the law where you are. What the court does depends on the facts and rules, including whether the loss was intentional.

Many people lose texts without meaning to, through automatic settings.

How it applies to text messages

If you may be involved in a dispute, do not delete texts, check Settings, Messages, Keep Messages, and make a backup on a Mac. See what to tell clients not to delete.

Ask a lawyer what you must keep.

An example

A man has a dispute with a contractor and starts deleting old threads to free space. A lawyer would tell him to stop and make a backup first.

Practical ways to avoid it

Stop routine deletion once a dispute is possible. Turn off auto-delete, back up the phone, keep old phones, and tell the lawyer about anything already lost. If something was lost by accident, say so early rather than hoping it will not be noticed.

If you use a work phone, ask the employer about retention policies. If you have a shared family phone plan, ask each person who has relevant messages to keep them.

If something was lost

If a thread is already gone, do not try to hide it. Tell your lawyer, write down what happened and when, and look for other copies, such as the other person's phone, a backup or iCloud. Early honesty is usually better received than a late discovery.

What to keep in mind

  • This page is not a guide to sanctions.
  • Duties and consequences vary.
  • This is general information, not legal advice. Rules differ by court and place; ask a lawyer or the court clerk what applies to your case.

Questions

Is deleting my own texts a crime?

That depends on the facts. Ask a lawyer.

Does auto-delete count?

It can matter once there is a duty to preserve.

How do I preserve?

Stop deleting and back up.

Export the whole conversation

TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.