What is the best evidence rule for text messages?

Short answer

The best evidence rule says that to prove what a writing, recording or photo says, a party generally must offer the original, though there are exceptions. For electronically stored information, the federal rules treat a printout or output that accurately reflects the data as an original, so a clear printout of a text thread is often handled under that idea.

Cover page of a TextExhibit PDF: conversation, participants and numbers, date range, source, time zone, export time, how the export was made, page 1 of 3 and a Bates number
The cover page of an export: case title, exhibit label, who, when, from where and how. From an export of made-up sample messages.

What it means in plain words

Federal Rules of Evidence 1001 and 1002 set out the rule and define originals, including printouts of electronic data. States have their own versions.

The rule is about proving the content of a writing. It is not a test of whether the message is genuine.

How it applies to text messages

In practice the question for texts is usually whether the printout accurately shows what is on the phone. A full export with date, time and number on every message is easier to show as accurate than a cropped screenshot.

Bring the phone if you can. Some judges like to see the original.

An example

A landlord denies sending a text. The tenant offers a printout of the thread and the phone. The printout is compared with the phone on the stand, and each matches.

Practical habits

Keep the full export and the phone, avoid cropping or editing screenshots, and note how and when you made the printout. If you must show a few messages on screen, be ready to show the full thread on request.

Ask the court whether it prefers the phone, a printout, or both. Practice varies from one judge to the next.

What to keep in mind

  • Rules and their exceptions are technical.
  • The rule does not decide authenticity.
  • This is general information, not legal advice. Rules differ by court and place; ask a lawyer or the court clerk what applies to your case.

Questions

Do I need to bring the phone?

It can help. Ask the lawyer or clerk.

Is a screenshot an original?

Courts differ. See screenshots.

Is an export an original?

It is a printout of electronic data. Whether it counts is for the court.

Sources

Export the whole conversation

TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.