What to do when your spouse asks for your text messages in a divorce

Short answer

Do not answer the request yourself or delete anything: send it to your lawyer, keep every message as it is, and let your lawyer decide what to produce, what to object to and when. If you are asked to produce texts, export only the conversations and date ranges your lawyer approves into PDFs with hash lists, rather than giving anyone your phone.

Transcript page of a TextExhibit PDF: each message with the time to the second and time zone, the sender’s name and phone number, page number and Bates number
A transcript page: time to the second, sender, number, page and Bates number. From an export of made-up sample messages.

Informal asks versus formal requests

A spouse texting “send me everything you said to her” is just a message. A request for production from the other lawyer, a subpoena or a court order is formal and has deadlines. In both cases the first step is the same: stop, keep everything, and call your lawyer. The general discovery rules are written down for federal cases at Rule 26 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure (listed under Sources) but state rules differ, so your lawyer’s reading is the one that counts.

What to do right away

  1. Do not delete any message, thread or photo, even embarrassing ones. See should you delete texts during a divorce.
  2. Turn off any setting that auto-deletes messages: Settings, Messages, Keep Messages, choose Forever.
  3. Make a backup of the iPhone so the current state is preserved.
  4. Give your lawyer the exact wording of the request and its deadline.
  5. Do not send anything to the other side directly.

How production usually works

  • Your lawyer decides which conversations, people and dates are covered and may object to parts of the request.
  • You export those conversations into PDFs, one by one or all together with a batch export.
  • Bates numbers, such as SMITH000001, are often added so every page can be referred to. See Bates numbering.
  • Your lawyer reviews them before anything goes out and may withhold some messages as privileged, for example texts with your lawyer.

Do not hand over your phone

Handing over the phone gives access to everything on it. Production is usually limited to the relevant messages. If someone asks for a forensic copy of your phone, that is a question for your lawyer. TextExhibit exports one conversation at a time and keeps everything on your Mac.

What to keep in mind

  • General information, not legal advice. What you must produce depends on the rules of your court and the request.
  • Messages deleted before the request may be questioned. Be open with your lawyer about anything that has been deleted.
  • An export cannot hide, filter or edit a message. If something is in the range, it appears.

Questions

Can my spouse make me hand over my phone?

Only through a proper legal process, and often courts limit what is requested. Talk to your lawyer before agreeing to anything.

What if I already deleted some texts?

Tell your lawyer. Do not delete more. Check Recently Deleted and backups.

Should I produce screenshots?

Ask your lawyer. Full exports are usually cleaner than screenshots.

Do I have to produce texts with my lawyer?

Messages with your own lawyer are generally treated as confidential, but your lawyer will confirm and deal with it.

Sources

Export the whole conversation

TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.