How criminal defense lawyers handle a client's text messages
Tell the client not to delete or alter anything, make a complete export of the relevant threads, and decide with the attorney whether the stakes call for a forensic examiner. In criminal matters, completeness and handling are especially important, and the phone may also be evidence in the government's hands.
Issues specific to defense work
- The client's phone may be seized or the subject of a warrant. Do not interfere.
- Client texts may be incriminating as well as helpful. The attorney decides what to produce, if anything.
- Reciprocal discovery rules vary.
- Messages from the other party may be in the prosecution's disclosure.
Using an export
- To read and understand the client's side before anything is decided.
- To prepare for the client's testimony.
- To compare with the prosecution's copy page by page.
- To build a timeline.
When to use a forensic examiner
If deleted messages, device integrity or recovered data matter, see when you need forensic extraction.
Practical cautions for the team
Keep client phones and backups in locked storage, restrict who can open them, and log each access. Do not review a client's phone beyond what is needed. Avoid sending client messages by ordinary email, and use a secure transfer.
If the client's phone has already been seized or searched, ask the attorney whether a copy of the extraction has been requested in discovery, and compare it with what the client can export, noting differences without drawing conclusions.
Communications with the client
Remind clients that messages sent now may be read by others, and that talking about the case by text is risky. Use a secure channel for privileged messages, and keep those separate from the evidence thread you are exporting.
What to keep in mind
- This is general information for professionals, not legal advice. Rules and local practice differ, so check the governing rules, the court's orders and your supervising attorney.
- Never advise a client to delete or hide evidence.
- An export is not a forensic image.
- Privilege and Fifth Amendment issues are for the attorney.
Questions
Should we export before talking to police?
That is a legal question. Ask the attorney.
Can I compare to the government's version?
Yes, using dates and times.
Is deleted data recoverable?
Sometimes by forensic tools, not by this app.
Export the whole conversation
TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.