How to handle ESI format requests for text messages

Short answer

Read the request for the form it names, then answer with what you can deliver: usually a searchable PDF for people, a CSV for data, and the original attachments, with the supervising attorney deciding on any objection. Federal Rule 34(b) lets the requesting party specify the form of ESI and lets the responding party object and state the form it intends to use, and the parties often settle this at the discovery conference.

TextExhibit Export finished screen listing the PDF, CSV, HTML and manifest.txt files, each with its SHA-256 hash
An export finished: the PDF, CSV, HTML and the hash list, in one folder. Shown with the app’s built-in sample conversations; the names and numbers are made up.

Common forms asked for

  • PDF images or text-searchable PDF.
  • Spreadsheet or CSV with fields: date, time, sender, recipient, text, attachment names.
  • Native files, such as the database from a backup.
  • Load files for review platforms.
  • Forms described only as reasonably usable.

How exports map

  • PDF: human readable, paged, page numbers, optional Bates.
  • CSV: one row per message, good for filtering and review platforms.
  • HTML: viewable in a browser.
  • Attachments: copied out as original files, with a list.
  • Manifest: file names and SHA-256 hashes.

Handling a form you cannot give

If the request asks for a forensic image or a native database you do not have, raise it early. See when forensic extraction is needed. Say what you can provide and why.

Test before you commit

If the other side wants CSV fields in a particular order, produce a short sample first and ask them to confirm it loads. A ten-row test can save you a second full production. Keep the sample and their reply with the matter notes.

What to keep in mind

  • This is general information for professionals, not legal advice. Rules and local practice differ, so check the governing rules, the court's orders and your supervising attorney.
  • Review platforms vary in the fields they need. Test a sample first.
  • The app does not produce load files.

Questions

Can I ask what form they want first?

Yes, a meet and confer is a good time. See meeting and conferring about texts.

Is CSV enough?

It holds the message text and metadata fields from the export, but not the layout of a printed page.

What about emoji and reactions?

They appear in text, with reactions listed.

Sources

Export the whole conversation

TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.