Should you produce text messages in native format or PDF?

Short answer

Produce what the request or agreement asks for; if it is silent, a searchable PDF with a CSV of the same messages covers most needs. Native for a phone usually means a database or a forensic image, which is not what a consumer export produces.

TextExhibit Export finished screen listing the PDF, CSV, HTML and manifest.txt files, each with its SHA-256 hash
An export finished: the PDF, CSV, HTML and the hash list, in one folder. Shown with the app’s built-in sample conversations; the names and numbers are made up.

PDF

  • Pros: easy to read, stable layout, page and Bates numbers, photos in place.
  • Cons: not easily sorted or filtered.

CSV

  • Pros: sortable, searchable, loads into review tools.
  • Cons: no page layout, photos only by file name.

Native

  • Pros: closest to the source, with more fields.
  • Cons: needs special tools and knowledge, may contain other data you did not intend to produce.

A practical combination

Produce the PDF for reading and the CSV for analysis, with the original attachments and the manifest. Say in your letter how they were made. If the other side insists on native, talk first about what it means and cost. See ESI format requests.

A decision path

Start with the request. If it names a form, follow it or object. If it says reasonably usable, propose PDF and CSV. If the other side insists on native, ask what they will do with it and whether a database that includes the whole phone's messages is really what they want.

Whatever you pick, put it in writing, and keep the same form across productions so reviewers do not need to learn two layouts.

Cost and proportionality

Native production of a whole device can raise cost and privacy concerns that a PDF and CSV of one conversation do not. If the other side insists on more, ask them to explain the need, and raise proportionality with the attorney before agreeing.

What to keep in mind

  • This is general information for professionals, not legal advice. Rules and local practice differ, so check the governing rules, the court's orders and your supervising attorney.
  • Whether a PDF is acceptable as the form of production depends on the request and the court.
  • Native forms can expose other data.

Questions

Is a PDF considered ESI?

Yes, a PDF of messages is still ESI. The question is form.

Do I need to give native too?

Only if required or agreed.

What does native mean for texts?

Often the database file the phone or backup stores messages in.

Export the whole conversation

TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.