How to give text messages to your criminal defense lawyer

Short answer

Keep every message exactly as it is, make a backup, and give your defense lawyer complete exports of all relevant conversations, including the ones that look bad, because your lawyer can only protect you from what they know about. Do not delete, edit or try to explain messages to anyone else, and let your lawyer decide what, if anything, goes to the prosecutor.

TextExhibit on a Mac: a list of conversations on the left and one conversation with a landlord on the right, with the Export button below
A conversation open in TextExhibit. Shown with the app’s built-in sample conversations; the names and numbers are made up.

First rules

  • Do not delete messages, threads or apps, and do not wipe or trade in your phone.
  • Do not talk about the case in new texts.
  • Do not message the other side or witnesses about the case.
  • Tell your lawyer everything, including what is on the phone and who else has access.

Preserve

  1. Set Settings, Messages, Keep Messages, Forever.
  2. Make a Finder backup. If you set a backup password, write it down for your lawyer.
  3. Export the conversations your lawyer asks about with TextExhibit. Each PDF has exact times and numbers.
  4. Add any other app messages by screenshot, and mention them to the lawyer.
  5. Hand the folder over by the safest route the lawyer gives.

What your lawyer will look for

  • Messages that confirm where you were or what was said, which may help your side.
  • Messages the prosecution may use, which the lawyer needs to know.
  • The timeline, to compare with other evidence.
  • Whether the messages the prosecution has match your copy. See edited and unsent messages.

Privilege

Talks with your own lawyer are generally confidential, but sending files to friends or posting about the case can undo that. Do not share exports with anyone else. See sending texts to your lawyer.

What to keep in mind

  • General information, not legal advice. Talk to your own lawyer.
  • An export shows what was on the phone or the backup.
  • Deleting messages after you know of an investigation can create serious problems.

Questions

What if I already deleted something?

Tell your lawyer right away. Do not hide it.

Should I give the lawyer my phone?

Ask. Often an export and a backup are enough, but follow your lawyer’s instructions.

What if I can’t afford a lawyer?

Ask the court about a public defender.

Export the whole conversation

TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.