How to use text messages to support an alibi or defense

Short answer

Give your defense lawyer a full export of the conversations around the time in question, with exact timestamps and time zones, plus phone records and other proof of where you were, because a text alone rarely proves a place. Do not delete or add messages, and do not ask anyone to send messages that would help you, since your lawyer will decide how messages are used.

Cover page of a TextExhibit PDF: conversation, participants and numbers, date range, source, time zone, export time, how the export was made, page 1 of 3 and a Bates number
The cover page of an export: case title, exhibit label, who, when, from where and how. From an export of made-up sample messages.

What texts can show

  • That you were in contact with someone at a certain time.
  • That plans were made, changed or canceled.
  • That someone else said something relevant to the events.
  • A photo or location sent in a message and its time.

What they cannot show alone

  • That you personally were at a place. Someone else could have been using the phone.
  • That a message was sent from where you say it was.
  • Anything after a message was deleted or edited.

Preserve and export

  1. Do not change the phone or delete anything.
  2. Export the whole thread, from a date before to a date after the time in question, with TextExhibit. Times show to the second, with the time zone.
  3. Note the phone’s time zone setting and any travel across time zones that day.
  4. Gather other records: receipts, transit data, photos with timestamps, workplace logs.
  5. Give everything to your lawyer, including messages that look unhelpful.

What the prosecution may argue

They may say someone else used the phone, that messages were arranged to create an alibi, or that times are unreliable. Complete threads and independent records answer those better than a few screenshots. For how messages are shown to be real, see authenticating texts.

Witnesses

The person you texted may be a witness. Do not coach them. Your lawyer can contact them.

What to keep in mind

  • General information, not legal advice.
  • Many places require notice of an alibi defense by a deadline, which your lawyer handles.
  • Time stamps depend on the phone’s clock and network.

Questions

Are text timestamps reliable?

Usually, but a lawyer may need carrier records to support them.

Should I send new texts to witnesses?

No. Let your lawyer handle it.

What if the person I texted deleted the messages?

Your copy still shows what you sent and received. Tell your lawyer.

Export the whole conversation

TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.