How to review text messages for privilege before production

Short answer

Export the whole conversation, read it, mark any message to or from a lawyer or relaying legal advice, and give the marked items to the attorney for decision before production. Reviewers should read the export, not the live phone, so nothing is changed or accidentally sent.

Cover page of a TextExhibit PDF: conversation, participants and numbers, date range, source, time zone, export time, how the export was made, page 1 of 3 and a Bates number
The cover page of an export: case title, exhibit label, who, when, from where and how. From an export of made-up sample messages.

What to look for

  • Messages with the client's lawyer, including earlier lawyers.
  • Messages forwarding or quoting legal advice to family or friends, where privilege may be at risk.
  • Work texts with in-house counsel.
  • Messages with therapists or doctors, which may be protected by other rules.
  • Third parties in the thread.

Process

  1. Export with TextExhibit and open the PDF.
  2. Mark entries with page and Bates ranges.
  3. Create a short log: date, sender, recipients, general description.
  4. The attorney decides what to withhold or redact.
  5. Re-export or redact per decision, and note it.

Redaction

The app does not blur text inside a PDF. Do redaction in your usual redaction tool or by choosing date ranges that exclude the item, and note it. See redacting text messages.

A privilege log entry

A typical entry lists the date and time, the author, the recipients, the type of message (text), a short description that does not reveal the content, such as message seeking legal advice regarding the lease, and the privilege claimed. Some courts want Bates numbers.

Keep the withheld pages with the attorney, and make sure the produced version has a clear note such as page withheld, so Bates numbers stay continuous.

Second look

Have a second reviewer or the attorney check a sample of the unmarked messages as well as the marked ones. Privilege is easy to miss when a client forwards a lawyer's email as a text or mentions legal advice in passing.

What to keep in mind

  • This is general information for professionals, not legal advice. Rules and local practice differ, so check the governing rules, the court's orders and your supervising attorney.
  • Privilege rules differ by place. The attorney decides.
  • Messages sent in front of third parties may not be protected.
  • A privilege log is often required if something is withheld.

Questions

Who decides what is privileged?

The attorney.

Can I strike one message?

Not inside the app. Use redaction software or cut by date, and document it.

Should I review the phone itself?

Review the export instead.

Export the whole conversation

TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.