Are text messages admissible in court in Massachusetts?

Short answer

Text messages can be used as evidence in Massachusetts courts, but whoever offers them must first authenticate them, under Section 901 of the Massachusetts Guide to Evidence, by showing they are what they claim to be, which usually means testimony from someone who sent or received them. Screenshots or a print from the Messages app on a Mac cost nothing and can work for a few messages; for a long thread, export the whole conversation to one PDF with the date, time and phone number on every message, and ask your lawyer or the clerk what format the court wants.

From opening a conversation to the exported files, in 30 seconds. Recorded in TextExhibit with its built-in sample conversations; the names and numbers are made up. Background music, no narration.

The Massachusetts rule on authentication

Massachusetts is unusual: it never adopted a numbered code of evidence rules. Instead, the Supreme Judicial Court publishes the Massachusetts Guide to Evidence, which collects the existing law in a familiar numbered format. Section 901 covers authentication, and section 901(b)(11) deals specifically with electronic or digital communications such as texts and emails.

In plain English, the person offering a text has to produce enough evidence for a judge or jury to find that the message is what they say it is, and in practice, that the person they say sent it really sent it. Under the Guide, authentication is a preliminary question of fact under section 104(b): the judge decides whether there is enough to let the evidence in, and the fact finder decides how much weight to give it.

Massachusetts courts look for confirming circumstances that tie a message to its author, not only the name or number in the header. Typical ones are testimony from the person who received the messages, replies that answer earlier messages, details only the sender would know, and the sender's own later conduct. The Attorney General's office publishes a Massachusetts Digital Evidence Guide that goes through text messages in more detail.

Hearsay: when the content is the problem

Authentication answers whether a message is real. Hearsay is a separate question: whether a statement made outside court can be used to prove that what it says is true.

The Guide's section 801 defines hearsay and section 801(d)(2) treats an opposing party's own statement, offered against that party, as not hearsay. So the other side's texts offered against them usually clear the hearsay hurdle, while texts from third parties (a friend repeating what someone said) often do not.

Screenshots or a full export?

  • Screenshots show what the screen showed. They often leave out the exact time of each message and the sender's phone number, and a set of cropped images invites the question of what is missing.
  • A full export of the conversation, or of every message in a date range, shows context and makes it harder to argue that messages were picked out. See are screenshots admissible.
  • Whatever format you use, keep the phone and the original conversation. If authenticity is disputed, the judge may want to see the messages on the device.
  • Do not edit, crop out or highlight anything on the copies you give the court or the other side. Mark up only your own copy.

Preparing the texts

  1. Free first: for a handful of messages, take screenshots, swiping left in the conversation so the iPhone shows the time of each message. If Messages in iCloud syncs to a Mac, you can also open the conversation in Messages on the Mac, scroll back to load everything you need, and choose File, Print, then save as PDF.
  2. For a longer thread, open TextExhibit on a Mac, choose where the messages are (the Messages app on the Mac, the iPhone over a cable, or an existing Finder backup) and pick the conversation.
  3. Choose the whole conversation or a date range. Check the preview: every message shows the date, the time to the second with the time zone, and the sender's name and phone number.
  4. Add a case title or exhibit label if you have one, then export. You get one PDF with numbered pages, the attachments in a folder, and a manifest listing each file with its SHA-256 hash.

What to keep in mind

  • This is general information about Massachusetts, not legal advice. Whether particular texts are admitted is up to the judge, applying Massachusetts law to your facts.
  • An export or printout does not authenticate itself. A witness who knows the messages usually still has to explain where they came from. See how to authenticate text messages.
  • Messages deleted before a backup was made are usually not recoverable by any export tool.

Questions

Are screenshots of texts admissible in Massachusetts?

They can be, if someone authenticates them and they survive any hearsay or relevance objection. A complete export with dates, times and numbers is easier to authenticate and harder to attack as incomplete. Ask your lawyer which the court prefers.

Does Massachusetts have Rules of Evidence like other states?

Not as a code. The Massachusetts Guide to Evidence, published by the Supreme Judicial Court, summarizes the law of evidence in numbered sections. Lawyers and judges cite it the same way other states cite their rules, for example section 901 for authentication.

Do I need to bring my phone to court?

It is wise to. If the other side disputes the printout, the judge may want to compare it with the messages on the phone. Keep it charged and do not delete the conversation.

Does TextExhibit make my texts admissible?

No tool can do that; admissibility is the judge's decision. TextExhibit produces a complete, consistent PDF with dates, times, numbers and file hashes, which makes it easier for you or your lawyer to lay the foundation.

Sources

Export the whole conversation

TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.