Are text messages admissible in court in New York?
Text messages can be used as evidence in New York, and because the state has no codified evidence code, courts and lawyers look to case law, summarized in the court system's Guide to New York Evidence: rule 9.01 requires proof that the messages are what you claim, and rule 9.05 lists ways to show it. Keep the original phone, make a free copy with screenshots or a Finder backup, and for long threads export the whole conversation with the date, time and sender number on every message.
Why New York is different
Most states have adopted a numbered code of evidence based on the federal rules. New York has not. Its evidence law comes from statutes such as the CPLR and from court decisions. To make that law easier to find, the New York State Unified Court System publishes the Guide to New York Evidence, which restates the rules in numbered form with notes on the cases behind them.
Article 9 of the Guide covers authenticity and identification. Rule 9.01 says the party offering the evidence must show it is what they claim it is, by evidence sufficient to support that finding, unless it is self-authenticating. Rule 9.05 lists methods, "not a complete list," including the testimony of a witness with knowledge and circumstantial evidence: appearance, contents, substance and internal patterns.
What the Guide says about text messages
The note to rule 9.05 says circumstantial evidence can be used to authenticate electronic communications such as emails, text messages and social media posts. It cites appellate cases where texts were authenticated by their contents because they made no sense unless the other person sent them, and a case where a photo was not authenticated because nobody tied the web page to the defendant.
In practice that means context matters: replies that fit, details only the sender would know, the number the messages came from. A complete thread with the sender's number on every message keeps that context in front of the judge.
Hearsay is a separate question, covered in its own article of the Guide. Whether a text is hearsay depends on who wrote it and why it is offered. See hearsay in plain English.
Screenshots or a full export?
Neither format is required by the rule itself. What matters is whether there is enough to support a finding that the messages are what you say they are. A few screenshots can be enough when nobody disputes them. When the other side says something was cut out, changed or taken out of context, a copy of the whole conversation, with the date, time and sender number on every message, is easier to defend.
Screenshots usually show a contact name instead of a number, show the time only now and then, and leave gaps between images. An export of the full thread or a stated date range avoids those gaps. See are screenshots admissible for the trade-offs.
Making a complete copy from an iPhone
- Do not delete the conversation, reset the phone or edit the contact while the case is open. Keep the original where it is.
- Free option: take screenshots, swiping left in the conversation first so each message shows its time. Make a Finder backup too (Finder, select the iPhone, General, Back Up Now) so a snapshot of the phone exists.
- For long threads, TextExhibit on a Mac reads the Messages app, the iPhone over a cable or an existing Finder backup, and exports one conversation to a PDF with the date, time, time zone, sender name and number on every message, plus a cover page and a SHA-256 hash list. Reading and previewing are free; a $24.99 one-time license removes the watermark.
- Write down when and how you made the copy, and keep the export folder unchanged. Then ask your lawyer or the New York court clerk what format they want.
What to keep in mind
- This is general information about New York, not legal advice. The judge decides what is admitted, and rules and case law change.
- An export shows what is on the phone or in the backup. It does not prove by itself who typed a message, and it cannot bring back messages deleted before the backup was made.
- If authenticity is seriously disputed, the court may want the phone itself, carrier records or a forensic examiner. That is a decision for your lawyer.
Questions
Is the Guide to New York Evidence binding law?
It is a restatement published by the court system to collect existing law in one place. The underlying statutes and court decisions are the law; the Guide points to them.
Which Guide rule covers text messages?
Rule 9.01 sets the general requirement and rule 9.05 lists methods. The note to 9.05 discusses texts, emails and social media posts authenticated by circumstantial evidence.
Are screenshots enough in New York?
Sometimes, especially when no one disputes them. If authenticity is contested, a fuller record and testimony about how you got the messages carry more weight. Ask your lawyer.
Sources
- Guide to New York Evidence, Article 9: Authenticity and Identification (NY Courts) (checked November 15, 2026)
- Guide to New York Evidence, rule 9.05 Methods of Authentication and Identification (checked November 15, 2026)
- Guide to New York Evidence (home) (checked November 15, 2026)
Export the whole conversation
TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.