Can text messages be used in a New York divorce or custody case?

Short answer

Yes. In New York only the Supreme Court grants divorces, while custody can also be decided in Family Court, and texts between spouses or co-parents are often used in both, subject to the judge's rulings on authenticity and hearsay. Save the full thread for free with screenshots or a Finder backup, export long conversations to a PDF with dates, times and numbers, and ask your lawyer or the clerk how exhibits are handled in your court.

From opening a conversation to the exported files, in 30 seconds. Recorded in TextExhibit with its built-in sample conversations; the names and numbers are made up. Background music, no narration.

Which court

  • Divorce: NY CourtHelp says the Supreme Court is the only court that handles divorce cases in New York State.
  • Custody and visitation: Family Court can decide custody and visitation, including before a divorce is filed (Family Court Act section 651). In a divorce, the Supreme Court can decide custody as part of the case or refer it.
  • Protection: the Supreme Court can also issue orders of protection during a divorce case.

E-filing and getting help

  • NYSCEF, the New York State Courts Electronic Filing system, has a section for unrepresented litigants.
  • Under CPLR 2111, e-filing is voluntary for people without a lawyer, even in courts where it is mandatory for attorneys. You can opt in and later opt out.
  • NY CourtHelp has plain-language pages on divorce and on preparing evidence. Court Help Centers can explain the process but cannot help you prepare your case.

Exhibits in plain words

CourtHelp explains that things offered as evidence, such as pictures and documents, are called exhibits once submitted to the court. A printed text conversation is a document exhibit. Bring enough copies for the judge, the other side and yourself unless the court tells you otherwise, and keep the original phone available.

Preparing the texts

  1. Pick the conversations that matter: usually the thread with your spouse or co-parent, and any group chat about the children.
  2. Export each one in full, or a full date range around the events, so nobody can say messages were left out. See exporting a date range.
  3. Free route: screenshots with times shown (swipe left in the thread), or File, Print from Messages on a Mac if your texts sync there. For a long thread, TextExhibit makes one PDF per conversation with page numbers, the sender's number and the exact time of every message, and can add Bates numbers and an exhibit label.
  4. Give your lawyer the whole export, not a highlighted copy. If you have no lawyer, keep a clean copy for the court and the other side and mark up only your own.
  5. Ask the clerk or your lawyer how exhibits are exchanged and filed in your New York court before the hearing date.

What to keep in mind

  • This is general information about New York, not legal advice. Each judge and county can have its own orders about exhibits and deadlines.
  • Texts you took from your spouse's phone without permission can raise legal problems of their own. Ask a lawyer before using them. See using your spouse's texts.
  • Do not delete texts once a case is likely. Deleting relevant messages can be treated as destroying evidence.

Questions

Can I get a divorce in Family Court?

No. NY CourtHelp says only the Supreme Court handles divorce. Family Court can handle custody, visitation and support.

Do I have to e-file in NYSCEF?

Not if you have no lawyer. CPLR 2111 makes e-filing voluntary for unrepresented parties.

Should I include the texts where I lost my temper?

Your lawyer needs the whole picture; the other side may have those messages anyway. Give your lawyer the complete export and let them decide what to use.

Sources

Export the whole conversation

TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.