Text messages as evidence in Utah
In Utah, the courts’ own self-help guidance says that for papers you submit, including printed messages, you must explain where they came from, why they are trustworthy and why they are relevant (Utah Rules of Evidence 401 and 901), and watch out for hearsay under Article VIII. Print the messages from your phone (free: screenshots with swipe-left times, or Print from Messages on a Mac), make four copies, share them in your disclosures where required, and be ready to show the phone to the other party before the judge.
What Utah’s courts tell people to do
The Utah State Courts’ Going to Court page is unusually specific about phone evidence. It says to print the pictures, emails, messages or other proof on your phone and make 4 copies: one for you, the judge, the witness and the other party. Videos go on 4 USB drives. If you cannot print, the judge might not accept the evidence, and if the judge does look at your phone, be ready to show it to the other party first. For remote hearings, contact the court to ask how to submit evidence.
Relevance and authentication: Rules 401 and 901
The same page explains, citing Utah Rule of Evidence 401, that everything you submit has to be relevant: it must help support some part of your case. Citing Utah Rule of Evidence 901, it says that for papers or videos you must explain where you got them, why they are trustworthy and why they are relevant, and that if someone else gave you the evidence, that person must testify about where it came from.
For texts on your own phone, that usually means you testify that this is your conversation with the other person, give their number, and point to details that show they wrote it. Ask your lawyer how much is needed if the other side disputes it.
Hearsay
The courts’ page warns that hearsay means talking about something someone told you but you did not witness yourself, that there are exceptions, and that Article VIII of the Utah Rules of Evidence covers them. It calls this one of the most complicated parts of representing yourself and suggests getting help. A lawyer or a legal clinic can tell you whether a particular message can come in, and for what purpose.
Disclosures come first
In most Utah cases you must share the evidence you plan to use with the other party through your disclosures, and the courts warn that if you do not, you might not be able to present it. The courts’ initial disclosures page lists electronically stored information such as emails, texts and social media posts. Protective order and small claims cases have no disclosure requirements, according to the same guidance.
Making the copies
- Keep the conversation on the phone and do not change the contact.
- Print screenshots after swiping left so each message shows its time, or print from Messages on a Mac.
- For a long thread, TextExhibit exports the conversation or a date range to one PDF with the date and time to the second, the sender’s number, page numbers, optional Bates numbers and an exhibit label, plus a SHA-256 manifest of the files.
- Print four sets and keep them in order, in folders or clipped, as the courts suggest.
What to keep in mind
- This is general information, not legal advice. The judge decides what evidence is admitted.
- Small claims cases in Utah use a more relaxed standard. See texts in Utah small claims.
- An export shows what is on the phone or in a backup. It cannot show messages deleted before the backup, and it does not prove who typed a message.
Questions
How many copies of my texts should I bring to a Utah court?
The Utah courts’ Going to Court guidance says to make 4 copies of everything you want the judge to see: for you, the judge, the witness and the other party.
Can I just show the judge my phone in Utah?
The courts suggest printing phone evidence. If the judge agrees to look at your phone, be ready to show it to the other party first.
Do I have to give my texts to the other side before the hearing?
In most cases, yes, through your disclosures. Protective order and small claims cases have no disclosure requirements, according to the Utah courts.
Sources
- Utah State Courts: Going to Court (checked November 15, 2026)
- Utah State Courts: Initial Disclosures (checked November 15, 2026)
- Utah State Courts: Small Claims (checked November 15, 2026)
Export the whole conversation
TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.