Text messages in Utah small claims court
Utah small claims cases (up to $20,000, usually in a justice court) let the judge accept evidence a reasonable business person would trust, so text messages are usually brought as printouts, and the courts specifically list messages as proof to bring to trial. Make free copies with screenshots that show each message’s time or Print from Messages on a Mac, save them as PDF or images if your case is in online dispute resolution, and bring printed copies and the phone to trial.
The basics
- Limit: $20,000, including lawyer fees but not court costs or interest (Utah Code 78A-8-102). Small claims can only ask for money.
- Court: usually a justice court where the defendant lives or where the events happened. District court is used only where there is no county justice court.
- Online dispute resolution (ODR): many justice courts use it under Utah Supreme Court Standing Order No. 13. The plaintiff must log in within 7 days of filing and the defendant within 14 days of being served. A neutral facilitator helps you try to settle.
- Appeal: within 28 days of the judgment, to the district court for a new trial.
The evidence standard is relaxed
The Utah courts’ Going to Court page explains that in small claims you can use evidence trusted by a reasonable business person, and the judge may also accept helpful and trustworthy evidence (Rule of Small Claims Procedure 7(d)). The small claims page puts it simply: bring any proof that helps your case, like photos, receipts, messages or witnesses, and the judge will look at everything and decide whether it can be used.
Small claims cases also have no disclosure requirements, according to the courts.
Texts in ODR
- Save your proof as a PDF or as a JPG, JPEG, PNG or GIF image. Those are the supported file types.
- In the ODR chat, tap the paperclip button, choose the document type and title, select the file and tap Attach.
- Keep copies of everything you upload. The courts say files uploaded in ODR are not part of the court case and cannot be used in court without your permission, so if you do not settle, you must show your proof again at trial.
- A single PDF of the conversation is easier for a facilitator to read than dozens of screenshots. TextExhibit on a Mac exports one conversation or a date range to a PDF with the date and time to the second and the sender’s number on every message.
Texts at trial
- If the case does not settle, the courts say trial is usually about 7 to 21 days later, and it is your only chance to convince the judge.
- Print the key exchange in full, not single messages cut out. The courts’ general advice is 4 copies of everything you want the judge to see.
- Bring the phone, charged, in case the judge wants to see the original. Be ready to show it to the other party first.
- Explain briefly who the other number belongs to and how you know, then point to two or three messages by page and time.
What to keep in mind
- This is general information, not legal advice. Each justice court may have local practices; ask the clerk.
- If the case is moved to district court for a jury trial, district court rules apply instead of small claims rules.
- Do not crop, edit or annotate the copies you submit.
Questions
What is the small claims limit in Utah?
$20,000, which includes lawyer fees but not court costs or interest, under Utah Code 78A-8-102.
Can the judge use my texts if I shared them in ODR?
Not automatically. The Utah courts say ODR uploads are not part of the court case, so bring your proof to trial if you do not settle.
Do I need to send my texts to the other side before trial?
The Utah courts say small claims cases have no disclosure requirements. Bring enough copies to trial for everyone.
Sources
- Utah State Courts: Small Claims (checked November 15, 2026)
- Utah State Courts: Going to Court (checked November 15, 2026)
- Utah State Courts: Initial Disclosures (checked November 15, 2026)
Export the whole conversation
TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.