Text messages as evidence in Vermont
In Vermont, text messages are usually offered as exhibits: printed copies you hand to the judge and the other side, which you must be able to identify and explain, saying what they are and where you got them. Make free copies first (screenshots after swiping left to show times, or Print from Messages on a Mac), keep the original thread on your phone, and print at least three copies of each exhibit for the hearing.
What Vermont’s court guidance says about messages
VTLawHelp, run by Vermont Legal Aid and Legal Services Vermont, has a page on going to court that names messages directly. It says that documents, pictures, or messages such as text or Facebook messages you want the judge to see are called exhibits. It tells you to keep exhibits well organized, be ready to tell the court what they are and where you got them, and print at least three copies: one for the judge, one for the other side and one for you.
For hearings by phone or video, the same page says you probably need to give out copies of your exhibits before the hearing, and to call the court if the hearing notice does not say how.
Why "where you got them" matters
Vermont, like other states, has written rules of evidence that the Vermont Supreme Court publishes. Courts generally expect the person offering a message to show it is what they say it is. For texts, that usually means a witness who sent or received the messages, plus details that tie them to the sender: the phone number, things only that person would know, and replies that fit the conversation. Our general page on how texts are shown to be real goes through this in more detail.
VTLawHelp’s guide to custody cases adds a practical point about hearsay: the court generally will not accept a letter or affidavit from someone in place of their testimony, and a person usually has to come to court and testify about the information behind a document. Text messages from the other party are a different situation from a letter written for the case, but the lesson is the same: be ready to explain the messages yourself, and ask a lawyer if you are unsure what the judge will allow.
Making copies that are easy to follow
- Leave the conversation on your phone. Do not delete it, edit the contact name or reset the phone while the case is open.
- Back up the iPhone on a Mac (Finder, General, Back Up Now) so there is a snapshot of today’s messages.
- Copy the whole exchange around the key dates, not single messages cut out of context. Swiping left in Messages shows the time of each message before you take screenshots.
- For long threads, an export is easier for a judge. TextExhibit on a Mac makes one PDF of a conversation or date range with the date and time to the second, the sender’s phone number, page numbers and an optional exhibit label such as Exhibit A.
- Print three copies. Mark up only your own copy.
Which Vermont court?
- Family court: divorce, parental rights and responsibilities, and Relief from Abuse orders. See texts in a Vermont divorce or custody case and texts for a Relief from Abuse order.
- Civil Division of the Superior Court: small claims up to $10,000. See texts in Vermont small claims court.
What to keep in mind
- This is general information, not legal advice. Whether an exhibit is admitted is up to the judge.
- We could not reach the official text of the Vermont Rules of Evidence when writing this page, so it does not quote rule numbers. Check the Vermont Judiciary website or ask a lawyer for the exact rule.
- An export does not prove who typed a message. If authorship is disputed, a lawyer may want carrier records or a forensic examination.
Questions
How many copies of my texts should I bring to a Vermont hearing?
VTLawHelp recommends at least three copies of every exhibit: one for the judge, one for the other side, and one for you.
Can I just show the judge my phone?
Bring the phone in case the judge wants to see the original, but bring printed copies too. Judges usually want something they can keep with the file.
My hearing is by video. How do I share texts?
VTLawHelp says you probably need to send copies of exhibits before a phone or video hearing. If the notice does not explain how, call the court.
Sources
- VTLawHelp: Going to Court in Vermont, What to Expect (checked November 15, 2026)
- VTLawHelp: Best Interests of the Child (evidence in custody hearings) (checked November 15, 2026)
- VTLawHelp: Small Claims Court (checked November 15, 2026)
- Vermont Judiciary (checked November 15, 2026)
Export the whole conversation
TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.