Text messages in a Vermont divorce or custody case
In a contested Vermont custody hearing, the judge decides parental rights and responsibilities and parent-child contact based on the child’s best interests, and texts between parents are often used as exhibits to show how you communicate, make decisions and support the child’s relationship with the other parent. Keep the full threads on your phone, make free copies (screenshots with times, or Print from Messages on a Mac), and bring at least three printed copies of the messages you plan to use, ready to explain what they are and where they came from.
The words Vermont uses
Vermont courts say "parental rights and responsibilities" for custody and "parent-child contact" for visitation. VTLawHelp explains that the court will never order joint custody unless both parents agree; if they cannot agree, the judge picks one parent based on the child’s best interests and sets a contact schedule.
Where texts fit the best-interests questions
VTLawHelp lists things the judge needs to know in a contested case. Several of them are exactly what years of parent-to-parent texts show:
- How well you communicate and make decisions with the other parent. Calm messages about school pickups, doctor visits and schedule swaps are evidence of this.
- How you help the child have a good relationship with the other parent. Texts offering extra time or passing on news can show it.
- How much care each parent provides: who arranged appointments, who did drop-offs, who answered the school.
- Any abuse. Threats or controlling messages are relevant here; see texts for a Relief from Abuse order if you need protection now.
Bringing texts to the hearing
- Pick the conversations that matter and copy the full exchange around each key date, not single lines.
- Make sure each page shows the date, the time and who sent each message. Screenshots alone often miss the date; an export from a Mac shows it on every message.
- Number the pages so you can say "page 6, the message at 7:42 PM" when you testify.
- Print three copies: the judge, the other parent, and you. For a phone or video hearing, ask the court how to send exhibits in advance.
- Be ready to testify about the messages yourself. VTLawHelp notes that the court generally wants people to come and testify rather than send letters or affidavits.
A practical way to make the copies
Co-parenting threads are long, and screenshots of a year of messages are hard to keep in order. TextExhibit on a Mac reads your messages from the Mac’s Messages app, from the iPhone over a cable, or from a Finder backup, and exports one conversation or a date range to a PDF with the date and time to the second, the sender’s number on each message, photos in place, page numbers and an exhibit label. It is free to try with a watermark; a $24.99 one-time license removes it.
While the case is open
- Write every text as if the judge will read it. Short, polite, about the child.
- Do not delete threads, even ones that make you look bad. Missing messages raise questions.
- Do not send messages designed to provoke a reaction you can print later. Judges notice.
What to keep in mind
- This is general information, not legal advice. Custody decisions depend on all the evidence, not one thread.
- We could not reach the Vermont statutes site when writing this page, so it relies on VTLawHelp’s summary of the best-interests factors. Ask a lawyer for the statute text.
- TextExhibit reads iPhone Messages only; it does not read WhatsApp, Signal or co-parenting apps.
Questions
Will a Vermont judge read all my texts?
Usually only what you put in front of the judge as exhibits and explain in testimony. Choose the exchanges that show the points you need to make, in full context.
Can I use texts if we agree on custody?
If you agree, VTLawHelp suggests writing the agreement down, signing it and filing it. Texts matter most when parents do not agree and there is a contested hearing.
Should I give my texts to the guardian ad litem or my lawyer?
Give them to your lawyer first. A complete PDF with dates and numbers is easier for a lawyer to review than screenshots. See sending texts to your lawyer.
Sources
- VTLawHelp: Best Interests of the Child (checked November 15, 2026)
- VTLawHelp: Child Custody, Visitation and Support (checked November 15, 2026)
- VTLawHelp: Going to Court in Vermont, What to Expect (checked November 15, 2026)
Export the whole conversation
TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.