Text messages as evidence at the BC Civil Resolution Tribunal and small claims

Short answer

In British Columbia, most small claims up to $5,000 are resolved online by the Civil Resolution Tribunal (CRT), where you upload evidence when the CRT tells you to, and larger claims up to $35,000 go to Provincial Court small claims, so texts are usually submitted as files online or as printed exhibits in court. Gather the messages early (screenshots with times, or Print from Messages on a Mac), keep the originals on your phone, and submit clear copies that show dates, times and senders, unaltered.

From opening a conversation to the exported files, in 30 seconds. Recorded in TextExhibit with its built-in sample conversations; the names and numbers are made up. Background music, no narration.

Which forum

  • Civil Resolution Tribunal: has jurisdiction over most small claims up to $5,000, such as things bought or sold, loans, personal property, contracts and roommate disputes. It cannot take claims about harassment, slander or defamation, or division of family property.
  • Provincial Court small claims: the BC government says its monetary limit is $35,000, and simplified trials at Richmond and Robson Square include cases up to $10,000.

What the CRT says about evidence

  • Evidence is material that supports your side or disproves the other side. Only give relevant evidence.
  • The CRT Rules say you must give all relevant evidence, even if it might hurt your case.
  • Do not submit arguments as evidence, and do not submit the same evidence twice.
  • Do not include what was said during facilitation unless the other participants agreed in writing.
  • Evidence must be in English or translated to English.
  • It is an offence under the Civil Resolution Tribunal Act to give false or misleading information, such as evidence created or altered by an AI tool.
  • The CRT will tell you when to submit evidence; start gathering it early.

Getting texts ready for upload

  1. Keep the conversation on your phone. Do not delete or edit messages.
  2. Choose the exchanges that are relevant, and include the full back-and-forth around each key message. Remember the rule about giving all relevant evidence: leaving out an unhelpful reply can backfire.
  3. Check each message shows its date, time and sender with the phone number.
  4. Free ways: swipe left in Messages before screenshots so times show; File, Print from Messages on a Mac that syncs your messages saves a PDF.
  5. One file is easier for a tribunal member than fifty screenshots. TextExhibit on a Mac exports a conversation or date range to a single PDF with the date and time to the second, sender names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers. Nothing is altered; edited and unsent messages are marked as such.
  6. Upload when the CRT asks. If you are in Provincial Court instead, print copies for the court and the other party and ask the registry about filing.

If the other side questions the texts

Under Canada’s and the provinces’ electronic evidence rules, the person offering an electronic record generally has to show it is what they say it is. Be ready to explain whose number it is and how you made the copy. See texts as evidence in Canada.

What to keep in mind

  • This is general information, not legal advice. The CRT cannot give legal advice or tell you what evidence would help your case.
  • Check the CRT and Provincial Court websites for current limits and rules before you file.
  • TextExhibit reads iPhone Messages only, not WhatsApp or Facebook Messenger.

Questions

What is the CRT small claims limit in BC?

The CRT resolves most small claims up to $5,000. Provincial Court small claims has a limit of $35,000.

Can I leave out texts that hurt my case at the CRT?

The CRT says its Rules require you to give all relevant evidence, even if it might hurt your case.

Can I upload screenshots to the CRT?

Yes, the CRT accepts evidence uploads when it asks for them. Make sure screenshots show dates, times and senders, and are not altered.

Sources

Export the whole conversation

TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.