How do I use text messages in a contractor dispute?
Texts with a contractor often show what was promised, what was approved and when work stopped, so save the full thread and line it up with photos and payments. Export the thread, then build a timeline of start date, payments, delays and defects.
What to look for
- The estimate and any 'we can do it for' messages.
- Start dates and promised finish dates.
- Requests for payment, deposits and your payments.
- Excuses for delays and no-shows.
- Photos you or the contractor sent of the work.
- Admissions about defects or promises to fix them.
How to organize them
- Make a timeline: estimate, start, payments, delays, defects.
- Export the thread, with photos inline.
- Add the contract, invoices and bank records.
- Add a separate list of defects with dates and photos.
Getting the texts out
If you spoke by phone, send a text summarizing the call, such as 'Confirming you will be here Friday'. It creates a record going forward.
A screenshot is fine for a quick copy. For a record that shows the full date and time of each message to the second, the sender's number and a hash manifest of every file, TextExhibit exports one conversation at a time to PDF, CSV or HTML from your Mac. The free version adds a watermark to each page; the license is $24.99, one time. See how to export text messages from iPhone.
What the other side may argue
The contractor may say you changed the job, delayed access or approved the work. The thread should show who asked for changes and who approved them. Be ready for them to cite messages from you that sound satisfied.
Who gets what
- Contractor: a demand letter with selected pages.
- State licensing board or small claims: the export and photos.
- A lawyer: everything.
What to keep in mind
- Licensing boards and courts have their own rules.
- A text cannot prove poor workmanship; you may need an expert.
- General information, not legal advice. Rules differ by state, agency and court; ask a lawyer or the agency itself what it needs.
Questions
Should I stop texting?
No. Written messages help, but stay factual.
What about a contract?
Texts that conflict with it can matter. Show both to a lawyer.
Can I withhold payment?
Ask a lawyer first.
Sources
- FTC: small business guidance (checked November 15, 2026)
Export the whole conversation
TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.