What text messages matter in a roofer dispute?

Short answer

Texts that show when the roofer was hired, what was promised on materials and warranty, and when they stopped showing up matter most. Export the thread and add photos, the insurance claim number and payments in one folder.

TextExhibit on a Mac: a list of conversations on the left and one conversation with a landlord on the right, with the Export button below
A conversation open in TextExhibit. Shown with the app’s built-in sample conversations; the names and numbers are made up.

What to look for

  • Messages about the storm date and the damage.
  • The estimate, the shingles or materials promised and the warranty.
  • Deposit requests and your payment confirmations.
  • Excuses about weather or supplies.
  • Messages about leaks or damage after the work.
  • Any discussion of insurance payments.

How to organize them

  1. Note the storm date and the date you signed.
  2. Export the thread from first contact to the dispute.
  3. Add before-and-after photos with dates.
  4. Collect the insurer's letters about the claim.

Getting the texts out

If the roofer sent texts from a number used for a business and a personal phone, export both.

TextExhibit (Mac, macOS 14 Sonoma or later) reads your messages from the Messages app, from an iPhone connected by cable, or from a Finder backup, then exports a single conversation or a date range to PDF with a cover page and a manifest of file hashes. Everything stays on your Mac. Free exports carry a watermark; $24.99 removes it. Start with exporting a date range.

What the other side may argue

A roofer may say weather caused delay, that you changed materials or that the leak has another cause. Messages that fix the schedule and the materials answer part of that. Expect the argument that you did not allow repairs.

Who gets what

  • Your insurer: only what it asks for.
  • State contractor board or small claims: the export and photos.
  • A lawyer.

What to keep in mind

  • Texts do not prove why a roof leaks.
  • Some states have rules about roofing deposits and insurance, so check.
  • General information, not legal advice. Rules differ by state, agency and court; ask a lawyer or the agency itself what it needs.

Questions

Should I pay a deposit by text approval?

Ask for a written contract.

What if the roofer ghosted me?

Save the final messages and call times.

Can my insurer see the texts?

Only if you share them; ask before doing so.

Sources

Export the whole conversation

TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.