Can text messages be used in a DC divorce or custody case?

Short answer

Yes, text messages can be offered as exhibits in a DC divorce or custody case, and the court's Pro Se Guide to Evidence in DC Family Court lists texts as documentary evidence and walks through how to enter a text message into evidence. Print the relevant conversation with dates, times and numbers, list it by the deadline in the judge's order, bring at least 3 copies to the hearing, and be ready to lay a foundation by explaining whose number it is and how you know.

From opening a conversation to the exported files, in 30 seconds. Recorded in TextExhibit with its built-in sample conversations; the names and numbers are made up. Background music, no narration.

Which court hears it

Under DC Code 11-1101, the Family Court of the Superior Court has jurisdiction over divorce, legal separation, custody of minor children, and support. Within the court's Family Court Operations Division, the Domestic Relations Branch handles divorce and custody, and papers are filed at the Family Court Central Intake Center.

Family Court cases are eFiled through CaseFileXpress (File & Serve Xpress), not eFileDC, which is for civil cases. The court's eFiling page says parties with a lawyer generally must eFile, while for people without a lawyer it is optional, and all eFilings must be PDFs. If you do not eFile, file in person at the clerk's office handling your case.

Free help: the Family Court Self-Help Center

The Family Court Self-Help Center is a free walk-in and call-in service for people without a lawyer in divorce, custody, visitation and child support matters. It can explain the process, help you pick and complete forms, and describe what to expect in court, but it cannot give legal advice. It is in the Moultrie Courthouse, 500 Indiana Ave. NW, room JM-570, phone 202-879-0096, Monday to Friday 8:30 am to 5:00 pm, with no new intakes after 4:30 pm. Its page also links Forms Help Online interactive interviews and a Pro Se Guide to Discovery.

How DC Family Court handles exhibits

The Pro Se Guide to Evidence in DC Family Court sets out these steps and tips:

  1. Watch the deadline. The judge will most likely set deadlines to submit exhibit and witness lists, and if you miss them you may not be allowed to use the exhibits at trial. The guide includes an example trial exhibit list.
  2. Mark each exhibit with a number (1, 2, 3) or a letter (A, B, C), before court or with a sticker from the clerk.
  3. Make at least 3 copies of each exhibit for an in-person hearing: one for you, one for the judge, one for the other side. With many exhibits, the guide suggests tabbed binders for the judge, the witness and the other side.
  4. At the hearing, show the marked exhibit to the other side, ask "May I approach the witness, Your Honor?", and hand it to the witness.
  5. Lay the foundation. For texts the guide's questions are: What is this? Who is it from? Whose number is that? How do you know? Who is it to? How do you know?
  6. Then say "I move to enter Plaintiff's (or Defendant's) Exhibit 1 into evidence." The other side may object, and the judge decides.

Getting the texts onto paper

  • Screenshots: free, but they often leave out each message's date and the phone number, which makes "whose number is that" harder to answer. Swipe left in the iPhone conversation to show times first.
  • Mac Messages: if your iPhone syncs Messages in iCloud to a Mac, open the conversation, scroll up to load it, then File > Print to make a PDF.
  • Finder backup: back up the iPhone in Finder (General > Back Up Now) so you keep a copy if the phone is lost or reset during the case.
  • TextExhibit: exports one conversation, or a date range, to a PDF with the date, time, sender name and number on every message, page numbers, and an exhibit label on the cover page. Free with a watermark, $24.99 once without.

What to keep in mind

  • This is general information, not legal advice. Your judge's orders control deadlines and format. Ask a lawyer or the Family Court Self-Help Center.
  • The guide notes that until an exhibit is admitted, you can only ask foundation questions about it. Do not start arguing what a text means before it is in evidence.
  • If a protection order is also involved, that case is handled by the Domestic Violence Division. See civil protection orders in DC.

Questions

Do I have to give my ex a copy of the texts I plan to use?

The court's evidence guide says to bring a copy for the other side and to show them each exhibit before you hand it to the witness. Your judge's order may also require you to disclose exhibits before trial.

Can we agree that the texts are real ahead of time?

Yes. The guide suggests speaking to the other side before the hearing to stipulate to authentication, which saves time and extra witnesses. It is still up to the judge to admit the exhibit.

Should I print the whole conversation?

Usually the parts that matter, with enough context around them that nothing looks cut out. A date-range export is a common middle ground.

Sources

Export the whole conversation

TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.