What if the other person used two phone numbers or an email for iMessage?

Short answer

Each number or email address is its own conversation in the database, so a person with two numbers has two threads that you have to export separately and then present together with a note. Search by name first, then by each number you know, and compare the dates so the threads do not overlap or leave a gap.

Transcript page of a TextExhibit PDF: each message with the time to the second and time zone, the sender’s name and phone number, page number and Bates number
A transcript page: time to the second, sender, number, page and Bates number. From an export of made-up sample messages.

Why there are two threads

  • The person changed phone numbers.
  • They texted from a work phone and a personal phone.
  • iMessage used an email address for some messages and a number for others.
  • You switched your own number or SIM.

Steps

  1. Search for the name and look at every conversation that appears.
  2. Search by each known number and email.
  3. Note the first and last dates of each thread.
  4. Export each with TextExhibit and label them, for example Exhibit 3-A and 3-B.

Presenting them together

Put a short note on top: "These two conversations are with the same person, who used number A until March and number B after." Provide both, in date order. See combining conversations. Do not merge them into one thread by editing; keep each as exported.

Spotting overlap or gaps between threads

Compare the last date of the old thread with the first date of the new one. If they overlap, the person used both at the same time; if there is a gap, ask what happened in it. A short sentence like "Thread A runs from May 2021 to Feb 2023 and thread B from Feb 2023 to date, with no overlap" is exactly what a reader wants to see in the index page of the exhibit.

What to keep in mind

  • The export cannot tell you that two numbers belong to one person. You must say how you know.
  • A number that is no longer in service may now belong to someone else; do not assume messages after a change are from the same person.

Questions

Does Contacts merge them?

If both numbers are on one card, the name is the same on both threads, but they remain separate threads.

Can the app combine both into one PDF?

It exports one conversation at a time. Combine PDFs yourself.

What about my own two numbers?

Your phone shows one thread per number or email of the other person, whichever of yours was used.

What if the old number was recycled?

Then the later messages on it might be from someone else.

Does the iPhone show both threads together?

Only if the contact card links both and the app combines them.

Export the whole conversation

TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.