Why Preview's Reduce File Size makes PDFs blurry

Short answer

Preview's Reduce File Size Quartz filter scales every image in the PDF down to a low resolution and saves it with strong JPEG compression, which is fine for photos viewed small but turns scanned text, signatures and stamps into blur. You can make a milder filter in ColorSync Utility, scan at a lower resolution to begin with, or use a tool such as SendSize that recompresses images at a screen-readable quality and leaves the text alone.

Make the PDF small enough to send Smallest or Gmail

What the filter does

Quartz filters are small recipes that macOS applies when it writes a PDF. Reduce File Size has one fixed recipe: shrink images, compress them as JPEG at low quality. It does not look at what is on the page. A full-page scan is one big image, so the whole page, text included, is scaled down and compressed. Small type loses its edges and becomes grey smudges; thin lines in signatures break up.

Apple's own guide to reducing a PDF's size says the result may be of lower quality than the original, and that size and image quality vary with the options chosen.

Fix 1: make a milder filter in ColorSync Utility

Try it on a copy, check the smallest text, and adjust. This is free and reusable, though finding the right numbers takes a few rounds.

  1. Open ColorSync Utility (in Applications, Utilities) and click Filters in the toolbar.
  2. Find Reduce File Size, click the arrow at the right of its row and choose Duplicate Filter.
  3. Expand the copy. Under Image Sampling, raise Resolution (for example to 150 or 200 pixels per inch) or set Scale higher; under Image Compression, move Quality up.
  4. Rename it, for example Reduce File Size Readable. It now appears in Preview's File, Export, Quartz Filter menu.

Fix 2: start from a smaller scan

Scanning a text document at 600 dots per inch in color makes a huge file no filter handles well. 300 dots per inch in grayscale is plenty for reading and printing, and makes files several times smaller before any compression. On an iPhone, the Notes app and the Files app's Scan Documents produce compact PDFs already.

Fix 3: compress the images at a readable quality

SendSize uses Apple's PDFKit with image recompression at a moderate JPEG quality and screen resolution, instead of the strongest setting. Text that is real text stays sharp because it is not touched. Scans still lose some detail, but the target is readable at 100 percent zoom. Pick a destination such as Gmail or type a size; if the result would not be smaller, the original is copied unchanged. More in compressing a PDF on a Mac.

How to check the result

  • Open the copy and zoom to 100 percent, then 200 percent, on the smallest print.
  • Look at signatures, stamps, handwriting and table borders.
  • Print one page if the recipient will print it.

What to keep in mind

  • Any image compression removes some detail. If every word must survive closer inspection, for example in legal or medical records, send the original as a link instead.
  • Quartz filters made in ColorSync Utility apply to your user account on that Mac only.
  • PDFs with a password must be unlocked before Preview or SendSize can rewrite them.

Questions

Can I undo Reduce File Size on a PDF?

No. The lost detail is gone from that file. Keep the original and export again with a milder setting.

Why is my reduced PDF bigger than before?

PDFs that were already compressed sometimes grow when re-saved. Keep the original in that case.

Does Reduce File Size affect text?

Real text stays sharp. Text that is part of a scanned image is compressed with the image, which is why scans blur.

Sources

Do it with SendSize

Make the PDF small enough to send

PresetSmallest or Gmail

  1. Pick Smallest, Gmail, or type a limit under Each file under.
  2. Drop in the PDFs.
  3. The copy is kept only if its text is the same as the original's.

Measured on an M3838 KB → 190 KB −77%

Free for 5 files at a time. $19.99 once for any number, on 3 Macs.