How to respond to a request for production of text messages

Short answer

Read each request closely, list who and what dates it covers, confirm with the client what exists, collect it, and draft written responses and objections for the attorney. Federal Rule 34 sets timing and form for responses, and state rules differ, so check yours and any court order.

From opening a conversation to the exported files, in 30 seconds. Recorded in TextExhibit with its built-in sample conversations; the names and numbers are made up. Background music, no narration.

Steps

  1. Calendar the deadline.
  2. Break the request into parts: people, numbers, dates, topics.
  3. Ask the client what exists and where, including deleted items and other devices.
  4. Collect with a consistent method. See collecting remotely.
  5. Review for responsiveness, privilege and confidential material.
  6. Draft responses and objections for the attorney.
  7. Produce and log.

Common issues

  • Overbroad date ranges, such as all texts ever.
  • Requests for the whole phone.
  • Group chats with third parties.
  • Messages the client no longer has.

When the client says nothing exists

Ask how they know, whether they deleted or changed phones, and whether a backup or cloud copy exists. Check yourself before saying so in writing.

Questions to ask the client

Which phones have you used since the dispute began? Which numbers and email addresses? Do you use iMessage, WhatsApp or other apps? Do you have Messages in iCloud on? Did you delete anything, change Keep Messages or reset a phone? Where are your backups?

Write down the answers and date them. They shape what you collect, and they help you describe your search in the written response.

Objections and honesty

If an objection applies, say so clearly and state whether anything is being withheld. Describing your search honestly, including limits like messages deleted before the dispute, is safer than overstating. The attorney decides the wording of every response.

What to keep in mind

  • This is general information for professionals, not legal advice. Rules and local practice differ, so check the governing rules, the court's orders and your supervising attorney.
  • An export does not cure an overbroad request. Discuss scope with the attorney.
  • Do not describe what was lost unless the attorney approves.

Questions

Can we object to producing the whole phone?

That is a legal call for the attorney.

What if the other side has already seen the texts?

Still produce if requested, subject to the attorney.

Do we need a log?

Many firms keep one. See production logs.

Sources

Export the whole conversation

TextExhibit turns a conversation into one PDF with exact times, names and numbers, photos in place and page numbers, on your Mac. Free to preview; $24.99 once to export.